One Tree Hill Makeovers – Love Them or Hate Them?

Posted on Jan 9 2008 - 10:18am by Angela | 21 comments

If you tuned into last night's episode of One Tree Hill (which you really should have done because it was amazing), you probably noticed that all of the characters have changed drastically in their appearances (which is understandable, considering it's four years later).

The question is, do you like the new characters' looks better now or before?

*Click to Enlarge Images

Nathan:

I think it's safe to say that most people find Nathan better looking in the previous seasons, considering he looked like a caveperson in last night's premiere, but hey, maybe some of you go for the scruffy, I-haven't-showered-in-four-months look. So we'll leave it up to you...

Haley:

Haley looked really good towards the end of Season Four when she had long, golden blonde hair. In last night's kick-off, she was sporting a shorter, more sophisticated ‘do that, in our opinion, made her look way too old for her age. What do you think?

Brooke:

While I'm a huge fan of Brooke Davis and really love her fashion-forward look now, I can't help but hate the change from brown hair to red. She looks like she did in Season One - which, in my opinion was the worst Season for Brooke.

Peyton:

Peyton's look really never changes too much but I've never been a fan of her appearance in all my years of watching the show. I didn't like the black streaks she added to her hair and I definitely don't like her choice in clothing. She's too skinny to be wearing tank tops and skinny jeans all the time!

Lucas:

Okay, for the past few seasons (especially when he went through that whole makeup and Elvis-inspired phase) I have hated the way Lucas has looked. But last night he looked damn good - especially when he was yelling at the high school boys during basketball practice. I think we're starting to see the Lucas from Season One again - and I couldn't be happier!

What did you think of the gang's new looks?

Bookmark/Search this post with:

Trackback URL for this post:

http://www.egossip.com/trackback/567

<< previous | next >>

Comments

Jason (not verified)

Definitely love Brooke's new look, Haley's new look and Lucas' new look. Don't like Nathan's (hope he goes back to the old Nathan soon)or Peyton's. I think Lucas' new girlfriend is pretty hot though!

OTHFan! (not verified)

I love them all. I think they all look appropriate for their new ages - except maybe Haley who looks too much like a school teacher and needs to look more like a 21 year old. And I'm not fond of Nathan's look but I'm pretty sure he'll be back to the old nathan in the next few episodes.

Anonymous (not verified)

I loved last night's premiere but I think most of the characters could use another makeover. It's like they tried so hard to make them look older that none of them look their age anymore. Well, except for Mouth, Skills and Junk :)

LoveOneTreeHill (not verified)

Nathan is the only one I think looks uglier now. I really hope they change him back to normal, but I think they will because he's normal in all the promo pics for season 5.

kristina (not verified)

i love Haley's hair! i thought it was so darn cute. Brooke's hair is okay, but i love Brooke - so it doesnt matter. Peyton.. well. i wish they could keep her hair straight or something. too many curls, looks like it's bordering a 'fro. lol. Nathan will get back to normal, i'm sure. Lucas is like Season 1 again!

Chelsea (not verified)

Last night, One Tree Hill was great! I like all of their makeovers. Nathan could use a shave, but Im sure he will once he gets back to normal. Haleys hair cut is flawless. Peyton looks classic with her hair. I love the color of Brookes hair, and Lucas always looks great. I have to say, my new favorite character is Haley and Nathans little boy, Jayme. He is so adorable. I can't wait to watch the next episode.

Lauren. (not verified)

OMG! i hope Nathan goes back to his old look i like fancying him and i don't fancy cavepeople :( Nathan get hot again pleaseeeee

valerie (not verified)

I loved all the looks except nathan love the hair but maybe a shave wont hurt and Payton she is beautiful just way to skinny!!! Jamie Haley and Nathan son is just the cutest little guy ive ever seen. Love the season premiere cant wait to see the episodes to come!!!

OTH IS #1! (not verified)

I think haley looks cute. Here hair keeps her young and yeah she looks like a teacher DUH she is a teacher! And she has to look a little sophesticated she's a mom and doesn't want to be a slutty one. Lucas well all i have to say in DAMN..he's HOT! his girlfriend is really pretty.And of course Brooke looks awesome and i love the hair. Peyton could use a different color more like blonde with a little brown but no black or maybe just not as much. Mouth looks to old for his age he needs a look like lucas shorter highlighted hair. & .....yes Jamie is soooo cute LOVE him he is my favorite too! He looks so much like Lucas!!!!

Anonymous (not verified)

I like haley's hair...but overall she looks too old!

Anonymous (not verified)

I really loved all of the looks at the end of season 4 but i also liked the looks last night too. i think haleys hair is really pretty short, but i loved it long. i think peytons hair looks basically the same. nathan of course is in a bad phase in his life so i'm sure his look will change. lucas looked amazing. brookes look was so amazing at the end of season 4 that i was kind of disappointed in her new look. i think it would probably be better if her hair wasn't red.

OTH Fanatic (not verified)

Love the new OTH makeovers!

Anonymous (not verified)

i love peyton in every season. she works the curls. i was definatly disappointed in nathan though and hayleys hair suits her:)

Anonymous (not verified)

OVER ALL I LOVED ALL THERE LOOKS, AND I REALLY LOVE NATHANS LOOK IT REALLY SUITING THE WAY HE FELT, THE DIDNT CARE LOOK, I LIKE EVERYONE ELES LOOK EXCEPT PEYTON SHE SHOULD REALLY GO BACK CURLY

Anonymous (not verified)

LOVE all the makeovers EXCEPT nathan!! I hate his long hair and scruffy face but I understand it goes with the storyline. Lets just hope it's cut soon! Besides him, I think everyone else looks great! Brooke definitely looks the part of a CEO mogul-glamorous. Haley looks like an adorable mom and teacher. love the short and dark hair! Peyton looks great and I'm glad Lucas cut his hair!

OTCFANFROMDAY1 (not verified)

I enjoyed the season premier for what it was, but I think I might have expected alot more considering how long I had to wait to see it. Nathan looks awful, but we all know that's temporary. LOVE LOVE lil Jaime. Haley looks too old with that hairstyle, it's pretty and all, but it's not age appropiate, trying too hard to look older. She looked better end of last season. HATE Brooke's hair color, but she is still beautiful and I'm liking her character even more. I think Peyton's face is getting a little fuller thus prettier, but she does need to do something with the wardrobe. As for LUCAS he is beautiful as always and I think he looks his best ever. The new GF seems nice, but he belongs with PEYTON. Looking forward to the season and can we please get past the whole Kevin Federline episodes FOR THE LOVE OF GOD!

Anonymous (not verified)

I disagree I thought Haley looked gorgeous! I really love her wardrobe this season. Peyon looked pretty as well but I'm not to fond of some of her clothing choices. Brooke's hair makes her head look huge, I liked her hair in s4. Lucas looked really hot, as usual. Nathan will cut his hair soon, he'll be hot in no time.

OTHFANFROMDAY1 (not verified)

For those of you who notice, please excuse my typo in my screen name from my previous comment. Don't know how I let that happen...and I call myself a fan! LOL!

Jessamie Carmant (not verified)

i love u guys omg i just cant stop watch and i cant wait 2 see more

Jennifer (not verified)

I think Peyton looks absolutely gorgeous this season - and she's not skinny, she's slim - she looks good in just about everything they put her in. Haley's hair is the only thing I don't really like, like Buffy would say it's 'mom hair'.

Anonymous (not verified)

I really liked the makeovers. Nathan and Mouth's are really the only ones I don't like. I think they did a really good job of making them look older. They can't look like they're in high school anymore, and they don't. Well done.